The Metropolitan Museum of Art LogoEmail

Type the CAPTCHA word:

Thank You Very Much, Mr. Roboto

Andrea Puccio, Assistant Museum Librarian, Thomas J. Watson Library; and Catherine Paolillo, Senior Library Associate, Thomas J. Watson Library

Posted: Wednesday, August 20, 2014

iPad sign in

iPad kiosk at the registration desk

«In early June Watson Library unveiled a new digital sign-in "book" to help us get a better picture of who is using the library. Attendance statistics provide a concrete, rather than an anecdotal, portrait of who is using the library, where they're coming from, and what their research needs are. This information can then be used to tailor our outreach efforts, direct our collection development, and improve or adapt our reader services. Though we have always had data on new users when they register for a reader's card, it is only now that we can track information about who is actually in the library at any given time.»

registration book

Watson's old sign-in book

Our old sign-in book was, as one patron put it, "quaint," and it provided limited, incomplete, and inconsistent statistics about our users. The book's size restricted the amount and scope of data we could collect: we were only able to get names, patron type (staff or visitor), and an institutional affiliation. The format confused many visitors and they often marked the wrong box, several boxes, or left whole areas blank. Even when the book was used correctly, poor penmanship caused us to lose nearly half the names and institutions given. Worst of all was the endless amount of staff time required to manually input the statistics into a spreadsheet.

sign in

Oftentimes we couldn't read what people had written down.

Rather than redesign the paper sign-in yet again, we decided to go digital. This gave us an opportunity to increase the granularity of our data, save staff time and effort, streamline the sign-in process, log an automatic time stamp for each sign-in, and have a system that could be easily modified and updated.

After researching numerous automated check-in systems (we tried everything from an automatic card swipe to a bouncer-style QR code reader) we ultimately chose the web-based survey software SurveyGizmo. Friendly pricing for non-profit organizations, as well as detailed, automatic, and customizable reports, a wide variety of customizable survey types with unlimited responses, the ability to fully edit the software's CSS, the best on-hold music ever, and seriously excellent technical support won us over. In addition, we can email surveys to event-goers and create forms and surveys for internal use.

local usage stats

Automated report on the occupations of our patrons

There was a steep learning curve involved, since neither of us are web designers and we had to make drastic CSS edits to force the web-based software—which is primarily geared toward email and embedded surveys—to meet our static (kiosk) needs, but we are satisfied with the results. You can click here to test a version of our final design.

As a result of all this success, we will soon be adding attendance kiosks at other public libraries within the Museum, and our Book Conservation department is even developing a form to track conservation treatments!

Although the response from patrons has been mostly positive, we have encountered some unforeseen issues. Notably, some patrons have a difficult time using the iPad. Also, spotty Wi-Fi can slow down the survey functionality, and the iPad must be locked up and charged overnight.

With that said, we continue to improve and tweak our sign-in to hit the crucial balance between extracting as much information as we can from our users with the least amount of effort on their part. It is a work in process, but so far, so good.

Department(s): Thomas J. Watson Library
Tag(s): circulation


  • Doris Coffin says:

    This seems to be a step in the right direction for many reasons. First, since people are no longer really writing anymore, just using computers, illegibility seems to be rampant. Secondly, if it saves time then it just makes sense. We need growth in all areas of life, best to go forward with the times even in a library. Good job, any thing that makes tracking easier is worth the effort.

    Posted: August 20, 2014, 1:06 p.m.

  • Lucy Oakley says:

    I'll never forget the thrill I experienced, as a young Met staff member in the late 1970s, of signing into the Watson Library and seeing the signature above mine: "Jacqueline Onassis." Future researchers won't get to experience this--but obviously the new iPad-based system has many other advantages.

    Posted: August 21, 2014, 7:03 a.m.

  • Sandy McKee says:

    We love hearing how our customers are using SurveyGizmo to make a difference in their community! Thanks for sharing how you have been able to streamline your registration process and collect the data you need to make improvements for researchers and students! ~ SurveyGizmo

    Posted: August 29, 2014, 12:59 p.m.

Post a Comment

We welcome your participation! Please note that while lively discussion and strong opinions are encouraged, the Museum reserves the right to delete comments that it deems inappropriate for any reason. Comments are moderated and publication times may vary.

*Required fields

Follow This Blog: Subscribe

About the Authors

Andrea Puccio is an assistant museum librarian in the Thomas J. Watson Library.

Catherine Paolillo is a senior library associate in the Thomas J. Watson Library.

About this Blog

In Circulation features in-depth articles and the latest news about the Museum Libraries' wide range of research activities and comprehensive collection of books, periodicals, electronic resources, and ephemera related to the history of art.