the subject, Philadelphia, died 1821; his son, Richard Willing, Philadelphia, died 1858; his daughter, Ellen Willing; her brother, Edward Shippen Willing, Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania (according to a label on the stretcher); his daughter, Ava Lowle Willing (Mrs. John Jacob Astor, later Lady Ribblesdale), died 1925; her grandson, Ivan Obolensky, by 1964 until 1966; with Robert G. Osborne New York, 1966
